In https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=1252902 I have cleared the Fixed in Version field several days ago, but blocker bugs app still displays the bug with [stable] tag and it links to the cleared Bodhi updates.
Fixed in Version
[stable]
{F32206}
It seems that Fixed in Version information is not updated properly during regular blocker bugs update. Maybe new information is added, but removed information is not deleted from that item representation metadata.
Note: AFAIK blockerbugs doesn't even look at Fixed in Version but links bugs and updates according to the information in Bodhi.
That would explain. Clearing the Fixed in Version field doesn't edit the Bodhi update, so it still claims to have fixed the bug. That's a bit of a problem, because developers are not used to go and edit Bodhi update information just to mark a bug as not fixed by that update, and QA people have no permissions to edit the update description for them.
I wonder how to solve this. There is a FailedQA keyword in the Verified field, when ON_QA changes back to a previous value, but I'm not sure whether it is cleared and when.
FailedQA
Verified
ON_QA
Maybe I should just remember that the Updates column doesn't mean "updates that fix this" but rather "relevant updates".
Updates
! In #625#8115, @kparal wrote: That would explain. Clearing the Fixed in Version field doesn't edit the Bodhi update, so it still claims to have fixed the bug. That's a bit of a problem, because developers are not used to go and edit Bodhi update information just to mark a bug as not fixed by that update, and QA people have no permissions to edit the update description for them. I wonder how to solve this. There is a FailedQA keyword in the Verified field, when ON_QA changes back to a previous value, but I'm not sure whether it is cleared and when. Maybe I should just remember that the Updates column doesn't mean "updates that fix this" but rather "relevant updates".
! In #625#8115, @kparal wrote: That would explain. Clearing the Fixed in Version field doesn't edit the Bodhi update, so it still claims to have fixed the bug. That's a bit of a problem, because developers are not used to go and edit Bodhi update information just to mark a bug as not fixed by that update, and QA people have no permissions to edit the update description for them.
Well, the Updates column says Potential Fixes when you hover over it :P
Potential Fixes
I don't know if Fixed in Version is always filled but if so, we can show the label (like stable, testing and so on) in the Updates column according to that field instead of guessing (which we currently do) it from all the potential fixes?
! In #625#8116, @mkrizek wrote: ! In #625#8115, @kparal wrote: That would explain. Clearing the Fixed in Version field doesn't edit the Bodhi update, so it still claims to have fixed the bug. That's a bit of a problem, because developers are not used to go and edit Bodhi update information just to mark a bug as not fixed by that update, and QA people have no permissions to edit the update description for them. I wonder how to solve this. There is a FailedQA keyword in the Verified field, when ON_QA changes back to a previous value, but I'm not sure whether it is cleared and when. Maybe I should just remember that the Updates column doesn't mean "updates that fix this" but rather "relevant updates". Well, the Updates column says Potential Fixes when you hover over it :P I don't know if Fixed in Version is always filled but if so, we can show the label (like stable, testing and so on) in the Updates column according to that field instead of guessing (which we currently do) it from all the potential fixes?
! In #625#8116, @mkrizek wrote: ! In #625#8115, @kparal wrote: That would explain. Clearing the Fixed in Version field doesn't edit the Bodhi update, so it still claims to have fixed the bug. That's a bit of a problem, because developers are not used to go and edit Bodhi update information just to mark a bug as not fixed by that update, and QA people have no permissions to edit the update description for them. I wonder how to solve this. There is a FailedQA keyword in the Verified field, when ON_QA changes back to a previous value, but I'm not sure whether it is cleared and when. Maybe I should just remember that the Updates column doesn't mean "updates that fix this" but rather "relevant updates".
! In #625#8116, @mkrizek wrote:
Er, actually I should think more before hitting the submit button. Scratch the suggestion :)
! In #625#8116, @mkrizek wrote: I don't know if Fixed in Version is always filled but if so, we can show the label (like stable, testing and so on) in the Updates column according to that field instead of guessing (which we currently do) it from all the potential fixes?
I think Bodhi usually fills that field when the update is pushed stable, not before.
The anaconda team fills in the Fixed In Version field when they commit fixes to the appropriate branch of anaconda upstream, but this is an anaconda-only thing, we cannot rely on it for other packages.
If this is an anaconda-only thing, I assume that the issue/RFE is invalid and I'm closing it as such. If I missed something, please reopen the issue and attempt to explain how we could fix this in a not-anaconda-specific way.
This issue has been migrated to Fedora Forge: https://forge.fedoraproject.org/quality/blockerbugs/issues/47
Please continue any further discussion there.
Log in to comment on this ticket.